Buy
Sell
Rent
Specials
My Account
Login
Manage For Sale Ads
Manage Rental Ads
Manage My Search Profile / Auto Notify
My Account Info
Manage My Favorites
Change My Email Address or Password
Logout
Advertise
Beach Real Estate
Beach Rentals
Join
All Locations
>
North America
>
USA
>
New York
>
Shelter Island
(11)
--please select--
USA
Bahamas
Belize
Canada
Cayman Islands
Costa Rica
Greece
Indonesia
Mexico
Spain
Turks and Caicos Islands
--please select--
Alabama
Alaska
California
Connecticut
Delaware
Florida
Georgia
Hawaii
Illinois
Indiana
Louisiana
Maine
Maryland
Massachusetts
Michigan
Minnesota
Mississippi
Missouri
Nevada
New Hampshire
New Jersey
New York
North Carolina
Ohio
Oregon
Pennsylvania
Rhode Island
South Carolina
Texas
Virginia
Washington
Wisconsin
--please select--
Amagansett
Amherst
Amity Harbor
Amityville
Aquebogue
Arverne
Atlantic Beach
Babylon
Baiting Hollow
Baldwin
Baldwin Harbor
Barker
Bay Shore
Bayport
Bayside
Bayville
Beechhurst
Belle Terre
Bellmore
Bridgehampton
Brightwaters
Broad Channel
Bronx
Brookhaven
Brooklyn
Brownville
Buffalo
Calverton
Cape Vincent
Carlton
Center Moriches
Centerport
Centre Island
Cherry Grove
Chili
City Island
Clayton
Cold Spring Harbor
College Point
Concord
Copiague
Cove Neck
Cutchogue
Davis Park
Derby
Douglaston
Dunkirk
East Hampton
East Islip
East Marion
East Moriches
East Patchogue
East Quogue
East Rockaway
East Setauket
Eastchester
Eastport
Ellery
Evans
Far Rockaway
Fire Island
Flanders
Flushing
Forest Hills
Freeport
Gates
Glen Cove
Great Neck
Great River
Greece
Greenport
Grove
Hamburg
Hamlin
Hampton Bays
Hartland
Henderson
Hewlett
Hewlett Harbor
Hewlett Neck
Hounsfield
Howard Beach
Huntington
Huntington Bay
Huron
Irondequoit
Island Park
Islip
Jamesport
Jerusalem
Kendall
Kent
Kings Park
Lackawanna
Lake View
Larchmont
Lattington
Laurel
Laurel Hollow
Lawrence
Lewiston
Lido Beach
Lindenhurst
Lloyd Harbor
Locust Valley
Lonelyville
Long Beach
Long Island City
Lyme
Malba
Mamaroneck
Manhasset
Massapequa
Mastic
Mastic Beach
Mattituck
Merrick
Mill Neck
Miller Place
Milo
Montauk
Moriches
Mount Sinai
Neponsit
New Rochelle
New York
Newfane
North Harmony
North Hills
Northport
Oak Beach
Oakdale
Ocean Beach
Oceanside
Ontario
Orient
Oyster Bay
Oyster Bay Cove
Patchogue
Peconic
Pendleton
Point Lookout
Port Jefferson
Port Washington
Porter
Portland
Pulaski
Queens
Quogue
Remsenburg
Ridge
Ridgeway
Ripley
Riverhead
Rochester
Rockaway Beach
Rockaway Park
Rocky Point
Roslyn
Roslyn Harbor
Rye
Sag Harbor
Sagaponack
Saint James
Sands Point
Sandy Creek
Sayville
Sea Cliff
Seaford
Seaview
Setauket
Shelter Island
Shirley
Shoreham
Sodus
Somerset
Sound Beach
Southampton
Southold
Staten Island
Stony Brook
Wading River
Wainscott
Wantagh
Water Mill
Webster
West Babylon
West Islip
West Seneca
Westfield
Westhampton
Westhampton Beach
Wheatland
Whitestone
Williamson
Wilna
Wilson
Wolcott
Yates
Youngstown
Sale Status
ALL
For Sale
Under Contract
Sale Pending
SOLD!
Price
-
0
$50,000
$50,000+
$75,000
$75,000+
$100,000
$100,000+
$150,000
$150,000+
$200,000
$200,000+
$250,000
$250,000+
$300,000
$300,000+
$400,000
$400,000+
$500,000
$500,000+
$600,000
$600,000+
$700,000
$700,000+
$800,000
$800,000+
$900,000
Any Price
Any Price
Beds & Baths
Bedrooms
-
Baths
0+
1+
1.5+
2+
3+
4+
5+
6+
Type
Home
Lot
Acreage
Condo
Apartment
Townhome/Townhouse
Commercial
Auction
Other
House Boat
ALL
More
Waterfront
Any
Yes
No
Water View
Any
Yes
No
Pool
Any
Yes
No
Square Feet
-
Lot Size, acres
-
MLS #
Ad #
Time on Site
Click Here to Select
All ads
Ads updated or added within the last 24 hours
Ads updated or added the last 3 days
Ads updated or added last 7 days
Ads updated or added last 30 days
Sort By: Featured First
Type - A to Z
Type - Z to A
Price - Low to High
Price - High to Low
Waterfront - Yes to No
Waterfront - No to Yes
Sq Ft - Low to High
Sq Ft - High to Low
Acres - Low to High
Acres - High to Low
City - A to Z
City - Z to A
Date Added - Newest
Date Added - Oldest
Beach Houses For Sale in Shelter Island
(1-11 of 11) Show
12 ads
20 ads
30 ads
50 ads
Grid
Map
FILTERS
Sort By: Featured First
Type - A to Z
Type - Z to A
Price - Low to High
Price - High to Low
Waterfront - Yes to No
Waterfront - No to Yes
Sq Ft - Low to High
Sq Ft - High to Low
Acres - Low to High
Acres - High to Low
City - A to Z
City - Z to A
Date Added - Newest
Date Added - Oldest
For Sale
$14,950,000
One Pandion is a truly exceptional and rare offering. Nowhere...
Waterfront
Home
For Sale
1 Pandion Rd, Shelter Island
6
8.0
Sq Ft: 6000
Acres: 3.400
View Details for
5199142
For Sale
$5,995,000
This stunning, fully renovated waterfront home features 4...
Waterfront
Home
For Sale
8 Cove Way, Shelter Island
4
5.0
View Details for
5609267
For Sale
$5,750,000
There is nothing like this magnificent water front modern with...
Waterfront
Home
For Sale
179 Ram Island Drive, Shelter Island
7
7.0
Sq Ft: 4941
Acres: 2.200
View Details for
4890269
For Sale
$3,995,000
Discover a secluded paradise on Shelter Island, nestled within...
Waterfront
Home
For Sale
47B S Ferry Road, Shelter Island
3
2.0
Sq Ft: 1800
Acres: 1.740
View Details for
4714011
For Sale
$495,000
Water view second floor condo. Open concept living, with two...
Waterfront
Condo
For Sale
13 Winthrop Road, Shelter Island
1
1.0
Sq Ft: 650
View Details for
4730021
For Sale
$4,200,000
Surrounded by preserved land this classic home has an absolutely...
Home
For Sale
156 Ram Island Drive, Shelter Island
4
4.0
View Details for
5609209
For Sale
$3,995,000
Step into timeless elegance with this iconic single-family...
Townhome/Townhouse
For Sale
7 Stearns Point Road, Shelter Island
9
9.0
Sq Ft: 5838
View Details for
5610282
For Sale
$3,600,000
This exquisite, light-filled, four bedroom, three-and-a-half...
Home
For Sale
24 Rocky Point Road, Shelter Island
4
4.0
Sq Ft: 3000
Acres: 2.000
View Details for
5007150
For Sale
$1,945,000
Situated in a quiet neighborhood, just a 5 minute from West Neck...
Home
For Sale
8 Tims Trail, Shelter Island
4
5.0
Sq Ft: 3689
Acres: 0.620
View Details for
5608142
For Sale
$1,350,000
Amazing 1800s house with 3 bedrooms and 2 baths. Perfectly quiet...
Home
For Sale
4 Duvall Place, Shelter Island
3
2.0
Sq Ft: 1200
Acres: 0.500
View Details for
3419175
For Sale
$50,000
Impeccable cottage ideally located in the heart of Silver Beach...
Home
For Sale
21 Peconic AVenue, Shelter Island
3
2.0
Sq Ft: 1691
Acres: 1.200
View Details for
4990387
More Cities With Beach Homes For Sale within 50 miles:
Amagansett
Aquebogue
Baiting Hollow
Bayport
Belle Terre
Branford
Bridgehampton
Brookhaven
Calverton
Center Moriches
Charlestown
Cherry Grove
Clinton
Cutchogue
Davis Park
East Hampton
East Haven
East Lyme
East Marion
East Moriches
East Patchogue
East Quogue
Eastport
Essex
Fire Island
Flanders
Greenport
Groton
Guilford
Hampton Bays
Islip
Jamesport
Laurel
Lyme
Madison
Mastic
Mastic Beach
Mattituck
Milford
Miller Place
Montauk
Moriches
Mount Sinai
New Haven
New London
Old Lyme
Old Saybrook
Orient
Patchogue
Peconic
Port Jefferson
Quogue
Remsenburg
Ridge
Riverhead
Rocky Point
Sag Harbor
Sagaponack
Sayville
Shirley
Shoreham
Sound Beach
Southampton
Southold
Stonington
Wading River
Wainscott
Water Mill
Waterford
West Haven
Westbrook
Westerly
Westhampton
Westhampton Beach
Reset all filters
< CLOSE