-
0
$50,000
$50,000+
$75,000
$75,000+
$100,000
$100,000+
$150,000
$150,000+
$200,000
$200,000+
$250,000
$250,000+
$300,000
$300,000+
$400,000
$400,000+
$500,000
$500,000+
$600,000
$600,000+
$700,000
$700,000+
$800,000
$800,000+
$900,000
Any Price
Any Price
-
-
-
Sort By: Featured First▾
  • Sort By: Featured First
  • Type - A to Z
  • Type - Z to A
  • Price - Low to High
  • Price - High to Low
  • Waterfront - Yes to No
  • Waterfront - No to Yes
  • Sq Ft - Low to High
  • Sq Ft - High to Low
  • Acres - Low to High
  • Acres - High to Low
  • City - A to Z
  • City - Z to A
  • Date Added - Newest
  • Date Added - Oldest

Beach Houses For Sale in Shelter Island


(1-9 of 9)   Show
 Grid  Map
Sort By: Featured First▾
  • Sort By: Featured First
  • Type - A to Z
  • Type - Z to A
  • Price - Low to High
  • Price - High to Low
  • Waterfront - Yes to No
  • Waterfront - No to Yes
  • Sq Ft - Low to High
  • Sq Ft - High to Low
  • Acres - Low to High
  • Acres - High to Low
  • City - A to Z
  • City - Z to A
  • Date Added - Newest
  • Date Added - Oldest

One Pandion is a truly exceptional and rare offering. Nowhere...

Waterfront Home For Sale

1 Pandion Rd, Shelter Island

6  8.0    Sq Ft: 6000  
Acres: 3.400  

Discover a secluded paradise on Shelter Island, nestled within...

Waterfront Home For Sale

47B S Ferry Road, Shelter Island

3  2.0    Sq Ft: 1800  
Acres: 1.740  

Surrounded by preserved land this classic home has an absolutely...

Home For Sale

156 Ram Island Drive, Shelter Island

4  4.0    Sq Ft: 3420  

Welcome to this stunning 6-Bedroom, 4-Bath Home with Water Views...

Home For Sale

61 Gardiners Bay Drive, Shelter Island

6  4.0    Sq Ft: 4949  
Acres: 1.040  

This architecturally distinctive home, inspired by the...

Home For Sale

24 Rocky Point Road, Shelter Island

4  3.0    Sq Ft: 2890  
Acres: 2.000  

This exquisite, light-filled, four bedroom, three-and-a-half...

Home For Sale

24 Rocky Point Road, Shelter Island

4  4.0    Sq Ft: 3000  
Acres: 2.000  

Tucked away on a shy acre, this private retreat features a...

Home For Sale

14 Fred's Lane, Shelter Island

6  4.0    Sq Ft: 2418  
Acres: 0.990  

Amazing 1800s house with 3 bedrooms and 2 baths. Perfectly quiet...

Home For Sale

4 Duvall Place, Shelter Island

3  2.0    Sq Ft: 1200  
Acres: 0.500  

Impeccable cottage ideally located in the heart of Silver Beach...

Home For Sale

21 Peconic AVenue, Shelter Island

3  2.0    Sq Ft: 1691  
Acres: 1.200  
Showing 10 beach properties within 20 miles:

Discover your perfect getaway at this stunning 3-bedroom...

1 View Home For Sale

2315 Mill Lane, Peconic

3  2.0    Sq Ft: 1900  

FULLY TURNKEY from furnishings, bedding / linens, towels, to all...

Yesfront 1 View Home For Sale

308 Wiggins Street, Greenport

3  2.0    Sq Ft: 1800  

Welcome to your dream summer rental in Fleet's Neck! Nestled in...

1 View Home For Sale

105 Fleetwood Road, Cutchogue

3  3.0    Sq Ft: 1846  

This 2-bedroom, 2-bathroom ranch home is the perfect lakeside...

1 View Home Sale Pending

58 Shore Drive, Old Lyme

2  2.0    Sq Ft: 964  
Acres: 0.250  

Welcome to your own waterfront oasis in this charming co op...

Yesfront Home For Sale

81 West Tiana Road b5, Hampton Bays

1  1.0    Sq Ft: 475  

Welcome To This Tiana Bay Estate Co-op By The Bay In Hampton...

Yesfront 1 View Home For Sale

50 Rampasture Road 6, Hampton Bays

1  1.0  
More Cities With Beach Homes For Sale within 50 miles:
Amagansett
Aquebogue
Baiting Hollow
Bayport
Bellport
Blue Point
Branford
Bridgehampton
Brookhaven
Calverton
Center Moriches
Charlestown
Cherry Grove
Clinton
Cutchogue
Davis Park
East Hampton
East Haven
East Marion
East Moriches
East Patchogue
East Quogue
Eastport
Flanders
Greenport
Groton
Guilford
Hampton Bays
Jamesport
Laurel
Madison
Mastic
Mastic Beach
Mattituck
Milford
Miller Place
Montauk
Moriches
Mount Sinai
New Haven
New London
Old Lyme
Old Saybrook
Orient
Patchogue
Peconic
Port Jefferson
Quogue
Remsenburg
Ridge
Riverhead
Rockaway Beach
Rocky Point
Sag Harbor
Sagaponack
Sayville
Shirley
Shoreham
Sound Beach
Southampton
Southold
Stonington
Wading River
Wainscott
Water Mill
Waterford
West Haven
Westbrook
Westerly
Westhampton
Westhampton Beach
Westhampton Dunes
Find More Beach Real Estate Here:

Alabama Illinois Mississippi Pennsylvania
Alaska Indiana Nevada Rhode Island
California Louisiana New Hampshire South Carolina
Connecticut Maine New Jersey Texas
Delaware Maryland New York Virginia
Florida Massachusetts North Carolina Washington
Georgia Michigan Ohio Wisconsin
Hawaii Minnesota Oregon  


International Listings:

Asia Canada Caribbean Islands Central America
Europe Mexico South America  
BeachHouse.com is a Member of the Dream Home Network
LakeHouseVacations.com
BeachHouse.com
GolfHomes.com
BeachHouse.com logo
Last updated on 2025-05-09
Copyright 2003 - 2025 © BeachHouse.com
Use of this website constitutes acceptance of our Terms of Use